Gershwin emerges in fresh colors following jazz-curious European contemporaries

Wed Nov 18, 2026 at 2:08 pm
JoAnn Falletta conducted The Orchestra Now Tuesday night at Carnegie Hall.

Looking back over a decade of performances in Carnegie Hall by The Orchestra Now, Bard College’s ensemble of graduate students preparing for orchestral careers, it seems the early twentieth century has been the group’s happy hunting ground.

That was when the one-way street from America to Europe in search of “culture” became a six-lane highway of mutual admiration. In the yeasty exchange of musical ideas and people, everything was allowed and anything seemed possible, even—sacré bleu!—jazz in the concert hall.

In Tuesday’s concert at Carnegie conducted by JoAnn Falletta, the young musicians sounded right at home with the hybrid aesthetics of East European émigré composers born in the 1880s and composing a century ago: the tonality-stretching dissonances of European modernism, sometimes stepping out to the catchy beat of American popular music.

In addition to energetic, committed performances, individual orchestra members provided verbal commentary, both spoken from the stage and in printed program notes on each piece. In addition, a “Concert Quick Guide” fact sheet on the composers and pieces was inserted in the Carnegie Hall Playbill. Lack of information was not a problem at this concert.

Falletta and her musicians sounded the keynote of the evening right away with chirping woodwinds and muted brass in the foxtrot movement of the Jazz Suite, Op. 28, composed in 1925 by the Russian-born, naturalized American Louis Gruenberg. High-stepping strings, a hearty tuba and swirls of piccolo rounded out this blithe movement. In a fast “Boston waltz,” strings soared over ambiguous rhythms and ripe winds-and-brass scoring.

The third movement started out as marked, “Blues tempo. Slow drag,” with a horn-trombone chorale, but soon developed into a kind of boisterous scherzo with crazy changes of meter. Here and in the energetic “One-step tempo” finale, the players executed accurately and produced the necessary beefy or screechy timbres, but Falletta’s reserved podium manner left out that note of nervous excitement that would have paid off in the accelerando coda.

The course of Warsaw-born Ignaz Waghalter’s life would lead eventually to New York, but he was 30 years old and living in Berlin when, in 1911, he composed his Violin Concerto, an attractive work that received its New York City premiere Tuesday night, with Mira Wang as soloist.

At that point, Waghalter’s music showed no transatlantic influences; his guiding stars were Brahms for orchestration and harmony and Puccini for melody and atmosphere. One might also cite Brahms for modesty in concerto writing; like Brahms’s, Waghalter’s concerto is plenty challenging to play, but almost entirely bypasses showy fiddle gymnastics in favor of purely musical expression.

The first movement was memorable for the orchestra’s sturdy opening statement, soloist Wang’s energetic, silvery-toned dialogue with horn and woodwinds, and her melodious solo cadenza in discreet double-stops. 

The violinist sang a deep melody on the G string over low winds and brass to open the Andante sostenuto, then rose high and more animated as her well-sustained monologue unfolded. The marking Allegro giocoso, con spirito exactly described the brief finale and Wang’s blithe performance of it, pausing the skittering sixteenth notes just long enough for a gracefully swaying theme, then putting a lively finish on this most unpretentious of concertos.

In 1910, Ukraine-born Lazare Saminsky was in his late 20s, studying with Rimsky-Korsakov in St. Petersburg, when he began composing Vigiliae, three movements on Russian symbolist poems. On Tuesday, it was not hard to imagine Rimsky’s Sinbad sailing his ship over the waves of cellos and low woodwinds in the suite’s opening Tranquillo movement, as flutes and violins filled his sails. The economical application of orchestral color was a lesson well learned both by Saminsky and by Falletta and her musicians.

“At the crossroads of existence…” was the line that inspired the second movement, in which chromatic lines climbed out of the depths as orchestral timbres glowed and faded. Falletta was somehow able to chart a path through the ever-changing harmonies and shapes. 

Journey’s end was celebrated in the closing Scintillante, which did indeed scintillate with piccolo, percussion and leaping strings. The music strode robustly ahead to finish in a burst of brilliance, and yet it still needed something—faster tempo? more energy?—to get the lead out.

A similar touch of heaviness hung around Ernst Toch’s Kömodie, composed in 1927, when Toch was 39 and living in Germany. Hard to believe, but this evocation of a jazzy, impudent night club show was premiered in that temple of classical music, the Leipzig Gewandhaus, with Wilhelm Furtwängler conducting!

The piece’s intricate woodwind foolery might be impossible at a faster tempo, but the piece needed something Tuesday to get it off the ground, so it didn’t sound quite so “classical.”  Falletta and the players did manage the layered texture well, with strings and high winds capering and constantly changing meters while cellos and trombones hummed smooth melodies down below. But with this conductor’s understated style on the podium, the piece’s hot, snare-drum-driven finish came off as just a slight crescendo.

After the music of émigrés or soon-to-be-émigrés, the program concluded with a notable son of émigrés, George Gershwin, and his An American in Paris. This piece found Mr. Jazz-in-the-Concert-Hall himself content to take in the sights of the French capital, pick up a tune or a taxi horn here and there, and write a musical diary entry about it.

Falletta and the orchestra took off at a fast clip and kept the music bubbling through the chaotic changes of meter representing Parisian street life. The pauses to reflect were well crafted and didn’t unduly interrupt the flow. It would have been good to hear the trumpet in higher relief in the blues episode, and the horns less prominent in the conga that followed, but the satiny strings soared nicely at that point.

Gershwin’s humorous coda and final rhetorical flourish were well timed, putting an eloquent cap on an evening of rarities that were at least intriguing and often beautiful, and one non-rarity that gained meaning from following them all.

The Orchestra Now and the All-City High School Orchestra, conducted by Leonardo Pineda with violinist Francisco Fullana, will perform works by Rossini, Mendelssohn, Mussorgsky and Tchaikovsky, 3 p.m. Dec. 20 at the Julia Richman Educational Complex, 317 E. 67th St. Free admission, RSVP requested. ton.bard.edu


Leave a Comment









Subscribe

 Subscribe via RSS