Carlisle Floyd titled his first (and still most popular) opera Susannah, […]
In his memoir, Words Without Music, Philip Glass explains that when asked to […]
If beautiful, lilting lyricism, waltzes, and a star turn by New […]
Looking back over a decade of performances in Carnegie Hall by […]
In theory, one goes to the Metropolitan Opera expecting the greatest […]
1. Mahler: Symphony No. 7. Gustavo Dudamel/New York Philharmonic Gustavo Dudamel […]
Music of Prokofiev, Still, Ginastera, Blache. Sphinx Virtuosi. October 17. The […]

There are more performances to come, but Saturday night in St. Michael’s Church felt like the culmination of this centennial year for composer Morton Feldman.
In the finale of the Graphic Content Festival, dedicated to music of Feldman and his New York School colleague Earle Brown (also in his centennial year), FLUX Quartet played Feldman’s extraordinary String Quartet No. 2.
On the surface, the most singular feature is the piece’s extreme duration. FLUX played the first full performance and recorded the piece in 1999, and violinist Tom Chiu’s informative program notes point out that at Feldman’s tempo marking of quarter = 63-66, there’s perhaps fifteen minutes between the fastest and slowest possible performances of the whole thing. (An early performance by the Kronos Quartet and a recording from the Ives Ensemble both abridge the work in some ways, e.g. taking fewer repeats than indicated). On Saturday, FLUX’s masterful performance began shortly after 3 p.m. and ended just before nine.
The ensemble—for this, violinists Chiu and Conrad Harris, violist emeritus Max Mandel, and guest cellist TJ Borden—is the first name for this work, and that they’ve worked out how to handle the excessive physical challenges is the least of it. They play the music, and that just happens to take six hours.
String Quartet No. 2 comes in myriad small, repeated units. It is a slow accumulation of events that in the end create a vast mosaic of sounds and ideas. Because time is what it is, this happens in sequence even though, if one were laying them into a visual pattern, each would be in a scattered location until the whole range was filled, all connected.
Watching the stained glass windows darken as the sun set, one thought of how songs and symphonies purposefully define a bit of time in order to show the listener where they are going, while much of Feldman and especially this piece work in a way closer to life, chance experiences without seeming purpose that one later examines for meaning.
One’s mind wanders to thoughts like this during String Quartet No. 2 because that’s part of how it works. One uses the bathroom, or stretches one’s legs. This reviewer spent the last 90 minutes standing and slowly moving to different positions on the wings. The crowd of about 75 was almost completely steadfast; some sketched, some read, some lay down in the pews. Feldman recognized that boredom would be part of the experience and didn’t expect anyone to stay seated or immobile, for the whole thing.
Except for the musicians. FLUX’s playing made it easy to experience the whole thing, and playing this is daunting not just for sitting in place for six hours, but having to play quietly, without vibrato, long and soft bow strokes, and with precision that requires constant concentration. Every unit of music has several exact features of rhythm, timbre, intonation, and specific number of repetitions. FLUX was, astonishingly, nearly flawless, and the small handful of inexact quarter-tones or wobbly intonation during a flautando bowing were noticeable in the moment, like a stone tossed into water, then disappeared just as quickly into the landscape.
Dynamics—essential in Feldman—were fantastic, not just measure to measure but in the overall shape. A feeling of expressive form grew. FLUX opened with a kind of knife-like approach, emphasizing exactitude. About three hours in, they found a different level, hand in hand with the piece moving into a long, repeated series of small units that rock back and forth, up and down, and are mostly tonal.
This stretch, which lasts up to the end, running through an extended coda section, felt like the heart of everything. The sound of the quartet, which already was superb, grew more beautiful. Still quiet, of course, and precise, it had a rich glow to it, each note both full and soft and perfectly tuned.
Feldman lays out ideas that would fit easily next to Stravinsky, Bartók, Debussy, even Mahler. It felt like the musicians heard this too, channeling their own responses to and impressions of other chamber music and putting those through both subtle shaping of the quality of each note and profound expressive feeling.
As with the opening of this festival, one heard musicians who recognize that, despite its unique qualities, this music is where the classical tradition is in the 21st century, and they placed this atop the shoulders of history.
In more recent history, this is process music, a different kind than Steve Reich’s. To get back to water as metaphor; Reich wrote of the experience of his music as like standing on the beach, letting the waves and tide roll in until the feet are covered. String Quartet No. 2 is full of waves too, the small units of music rise and fall, come in and recede. But there’s no vantage point like in Reich, no apparent history we stand on as reference. String Quartet No. 2 starts in the middle of the ocean, all waves and endless horizon. It moves us along without destination or change in the horizon. It is a new experience of an old tradition, easy to trust when played as incredibly well as FLUX.
Candide Quartet
Leonard Bernstein (arr. Krinke): Overture to Candide
Wyntom […]
Music of Morton Feldman and Earle BrownGraphic Content FestivalSeptember 11-November 21 […]
Carnegie Hall’s 2026-2027 schedule promises some of the most substantial and […]