If János Balázs were a boxer, he would have the best […]
Giacomo Puccini was such a red-blooded man of the theater that […]
Arguments over the classical canon boil down to how the output […]
“Sold Out” was plastered across the marquee for Aigul Akhmetshina’s Zankel […]
There was a sense of occasion about the concert by the […]
1. Mahler: Symphony No. 7. Gustavo Dudamel/New York Philharmonic Gustavo Dudamel […]
Music of Prokofiev, Still, Ginastera, Blache. Sphinx Virtuosi. October 17. The […]

In theory, one goes to the Metropolitan Opera expecting the greatest operas from the standard repertoire and new operas in the hope that they might become repertory works. In practice, the understandable pressures of business—with accompanying fandom over certain singers, conductors, and directors—mean seasons get overweighted by certain composers, leaving some of the greatest works in the repertoire in the niches or ignored altogether.
Leos Janáček’s Jenůfa is one of the greatest operas in the literature, by one of the greatest opera composers. The work premiered in 1904 and first played at the Met twenty years after that. Until the 1970s, it was hampered by both dubious “improvements” to the orchestration and a libretto translated into German, then English. Only in the last thirty years has the original version appeared at the Met.
Jenůfa returned on Monday night in a locally new production from Claus Guth. Leading the cast in the title role is soprano Asmik Grigorian, pursued romantically and sexually by her cousins (who are half-brothers) Števa and Laca (tenors Ryan Capozzo and Sean Panikkar). Soprano Nina Stemme sings the role of Kostelnička, Jenůfa’s step-mother. Conductor Tomáš Hanus makes his Met debut in the pit.
That the highly touted production proved the most negligible part of the experience in no way detracted from the evening, which was musically and expressively as affecting as one will find at the Met this season,
Jenůfa is great because it does what opera is designed to do, as well as it can be done. Milan Kundera has argued that it is one of the first prose operas, and the way Janáček tailored his libretto (adapted from a play), is an absolute lesson in how to use just enough speech-like text to have the music fill in what the characters aren’t saying. Janáček also, crucially, crafts an exceptional large-scale form that has the music constantly building the drama and moving it toward the conclusion—Jenůfa is one of the minority of operas that seems like it keeps getting better every moment.
And what music! Further Janáček’s word-setting is unsurpassed and melds musical and linguistic rhythms, idiosyncratic orchestration, shifting moods and the unsurpassed mix of pain and tenderness.
At the center of this is Jenůfa, who loves Števa and is secretly pregnant by him. The other characters around her do some of the worst things imaginable. Števa abandoning her is the least of it; Laca disfigures her out of jealousy, and Kostelnička murders her baby, thinking it’s the only way Jenůfa can fine love with Laca, who finds himself both full of shame and genuine love for Jenůfa.
Grigorian carved out an enormous center of gravity for herself with the sheer beauty of her singing. Her sound was gorgeous from the start, full and rounded, centered in the music. Her timbre was even in every register, and she never overdid anything. Janáček’s music is so full of force and meaning that the key to an exceptional performance like Grigorian’s is that a judicious amount of expressive inflection is all that’s needed.

The other main characters were mostly well-sung. The main variable in the performance was Stemme as the Kostelnička.
The dark weight of her sound was a fine counterpart to Grigorian, a kind of light/shadow, youth/age duality that created an effective contrast between innocence and (misguided) experience.
The problem wasn’t the quality of Stemme’s voice or her singing, though she had some wobbly moments on sustained tones. It was the vocal interpretation that at times went off target. In the music that has Kostelnička at emotional extremes, particularly Act II and Act III, she consistently fell into a Wagnerian style. This wasn’t bad in itself, but seemed out of place in this context of Janáček’s lyrical and emotional colors. Those are best painted with a variety of finer brushes, as Grigorian did, not the sheer size and weight of a big voice.
At their best, the two half-brothers were excellent. Capozzo captured Števa’s vanity and immaturity, and Panikkar was in Laca’s furious swings of emotion and perspective. In Act I, Capozzo was pushing his voice a bit, but grew more fluid as things went on’ conversely Panikkar seemed to suffer from fatigue at the start of Act III but found more strength at the end.
Like Grigorian, both showed fine expressive modulation. Capozzo was aptly swaggering in Act I and then cowed in Act III, not least by the shining, assured debut by soprano Erica Petrocelli as his betrothed, Karolka. Panikkar’s singing grew in depth and characterization as Laca himself considers his actions and feelings and becomes a full figure. Even in moments when he showed some vocal strain, he maintained full expression of the character’s emotional complexity.
Conductor Hanus was impressive in his debut. He was fully in support of the singers by focusing on the orchestra and the details of the music, putting the colors and timbres in full relief. Tempos were just right, and the energy was focused all evening.
Conductor Hanus was impressive in his debut. He was fully in support of the singers by focusing on the orchestra and the details of the music, putting the colors and timbres in full relief. Tempos were just right, and the energy was focused all evening. Most impressive was his handle on the overall form. Act I was energetic, and he kept a strong drive on the low-gear, introspective, deep music of Act II. His scaled the climactic, luxuriantly beautiful “Vstante” at the penultimate moment of the opera to s seeming peak, then managed the glowing, marvelous duet “Odesli”—the actual finale—with a rich feeling of resolution.
Guth’s production was adequate in the sense that it put the singers on stage and let them do their thing. The promotional and program language is full of the idea that Jenůfa is “psychologically astute,” which might mean that Janáček was connecting to the realism of life, confused thoughts, regrets and desires, on the scale of people rather than archetypes.
Guth puts that into a series of asylum-like cages. This is too obvious to even be called a metaphor, but it does lead to some marvelous lighting by James Farncombe in Act II, though also some pretentious and meaningless blocking. The staging is minimal in the sense that there’s one small, thin idea. To be fair, the setting for Act III is simple and lovely, flower petals strewn on the stage, which the singers set aglow.
Jenůfa runs through December 4. Asmik Grigorian sings in recital at 7:30 p.m. Wednesday at the Met. metopera.org
The Orchestra Now
JoAnn Falletta, conductor
Mira Wang, violinist […]
Music of Morton Feldman and Earle BrownGraphic Content FestivalSeptember 11-November 21 […]
Carnegie Hall’s 2026-2027 schedule promises some of the most substantial and […]